My journey from
Bangladesh to the United States was not just a long journey of 40 hours. It was
an exploration of identity, culture and the concept of “home.” As a girl,
growing up in a Bangladeshi Muslim family, home was an idea that combined
cultural norms, expectations from family, and the varied roles and restrictions
that were imposed to women. From a feminist perspective, this journey has
revealed the layers of navigating multiple identities and the fluidity of home
as a space. In traditional Bangladesh, women are expected to play the role as a
caretaker, good mother, obedient daughter, and potential wife at home. Here,
the concept of “home” for woman often means numerous obligation and
restriction. Home is not just a physical place here but also a symbolic space
where one’s acts, behavior, freedom, and even dreams are controlled. This idea
of women’s roles imposed by culture and society was pointed by Whitson (2017) in
Spaces of Culture and Identity Production: Home, Consumption, and the Media where
the author referred the concept of viewing woman “as victims of culture” that
connects culture, power and identity. Yet, stepping into the U.S. did not change
these complexities; it added new dimensions to what home and identity could
mean to me.
Photograph: During my journey to USA at
Istanbul Airport
One of my earliest childhood
memories that I can still remember is when I was about eight years old. My
mother, a strong determined woman, always encouraged me and my sisters (We are
three sisters) to dream big and focus on our studies. However, not everyone in
our family had the same vision. I can remember one incident when some of our
relatives visited our home. The living room was full of the smell of freshly
brewed tea and the chatter of aunts and uncles. As the conversation shifted somehow
to family matters, one of my uncles turned to my mother and asked, “What’s the benefit
of educating your daughters so much? After all, they’ll just end up in someone
else’s house.” He laughed dismissively, and others chimed in with similar
sentiments. Another relative added, “You’re wasting your husband’s money on
these girls. If only you had a son to make the family proud. “Then my mom
replied, “one day my daughters will make us proud, they don’t need a brother to
make themselves valuable”. Her strong words shaped my understanding of gender
roles, education and how people in a patriarchic society devalue women’s
potential at a very early age. Despite constant criticism, my parents never get
hurt for having three daughters and not having a son. However, a study
conducted by the University of Kent in the UK has showed a decline in "son
preference" by women of childbearing age in Bangladesh. The study also
shows that decisions on fertility are still influenced according to son
preference. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0305750X20304812
My migration to the U.S.
has insisted me to rethink what home meant to me, away from the expectations of
a traditional family and the cultural boundaries back in Bangladesh. But the
idea of home is dynamic. It fluctuates between the bitter memories of childhood
as female child and the lived reality of being a foreign student in a new land
as an adult woman. My journey is not about choosing one home over another but
about creating a sense of belonging that reflects the plurality of my
experiences as a woman.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteHi Nusrat,
ReplyDeleteYour blog is so beautifully crafted. It is simply written but has deep indications about the role of space and its impacts on how women are perceived in different spaces. First of all, your picture made me emotional as it reminded me of my personal transition from Nepal to the states. Coming from the same region, I can highly relate what it means to me a woman in that "South Asian idea of space''. It felt as if you were narrating my own story because my parents also have only daughters whom they raised with immense love and support which always motivates me to do better.
I agree, different spaces have different views on women and societies in developing countries like Bangladesh and Nepal are male dominated. When I was in Nepal, my independent nature was always questioned because the society always perceived women as weak and dependent. There were any instances where I could not do things only because I am a woman. I was in a space where I was expected to behave, act, and respond according to the patriarchal societal norms. Moreover, after coming to U.S, I realized how much a space, or a place can empower and encourage someone because here I am in a space where I don't have to limit myself and free myself from the chains of patriarchy. I feel liberated and independent, and no one questions my identity as a woman. Also, I would not underestimate the importance of physical because now I realize no matter how much a space makes me feel liberated mentally, I still desire for that physical space where I was born, where my house is, where my closed ones are even if that is a space where the society regards women as a second gender. This connects me to what Oberhauser et al. (2017) states in chapter 3 (Spaces of Culture and Identity production) of their book Feminist Spaces - " homemaking doesn't mean turning house into a home but also construction of individuality towards inclusion and belonging. Home is not only about physical space or a mental state with sense of belonging, but it is a combination of both.
Oberhauser, A., Fluri, J., Whitson, R., & Mollett, S. (2017). Feminist Spaces: Gender and Geography in a Global Context (1st ed.). Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/978131568427
Hi Nusrat,
ReplyDeleteThis was a really enlightening and pleasant read! I loved hearing how your mother and father support you and your sisters even if the culture and other family didn't. Having that motivation is incredibly important to someone's educational career and in one's life. Thank you for sharing!